Analysis: For Clinton, tough talk but few results
CAIRO — Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton's tense exchanges with Pakistani civilians and Arab diplomats over a harrowing week of foreign stops exposed the confining limits of her office.
On her most ambitious and contentious overseas trip as secretary of state, Clinton had to resort to damage control after she appeared to mangle the Obama administration's message on frozen Mideast peace talks.
And while she scored points back home by standing up to angry Pakistanis who confronted her about drone-launched U.S. missile strikes, her blunt questioning of the resolve of Pakistan's government exposed American impatience with the country's incremental steps against terrorists.
In each case her extraordinarily public approach to diplomacy — for better or worse — reflected not only her personal style but also President Barack Obama's promise to reach out openly to friend as well as foe.
What remains less clear is whether Clinton's hot-button politician's persona works any better at producing international results — let alone clarity — than a more classic diplomat's cooler tact.
What's interesting about this is Hilary is following in the footsteps of the Bush Administration and Condoleeza Rice. There is little difference in the two approaches. And yet, the AP attempts to make it sound like Hilary is blazing some new trail.
Her tough talk is just an echo of what Bush and Condi had already been doing for the past eight years.
The problem is, tough talk does not work when it is not backed up by a real threat of force. It didn't work for Bush (see Iran), and it won't work for Hilary, who represents an Administration which has even less resolve then the Bush Administration.
- Hilary Clinton Warns Revolutionary Guard Taking Over Iran
Hilary says, Iran is becoming a Military Dictatorship. From the Associated Press: DOHA, Qatar – U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said Monday that Iran is becoming a military dictatorship, a new U.S. accusation in the midst of rising tensions...
- Hilary "going Rogue" - Tells Latin America: 'think Twice' About Iran Ties
From AFP: WASHINGTON (AFP) – US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton warned Latin American countries Friday to "think twice" about fostering ties with Iran because of its alleged support for terrorism. "I think if people want to flirt with Iran,...
- Tough Talk From Hilary: Hillary Clinton: Iran Pursuit Of Nukes 'futile'
From Politico: Secretary of StateHillary Clintonsaid on NBC’s “Meet the Press” on Sunday thatIranwill never achieve its goal of obtaining a nuclear weapon, declaring to Tehran: "Your pursuit is futile.""What we want to do is to send a message...
- Clinton Raises Alarms About Spiraling Security In Pakistan
h/t Ro -- it's on Fox, too, Ro. So that lends it the little more cred you were looking for. Fox News: Clinton Raises Alarms About Spiraling Security in Pakistan In back-to-back days of testimony on Capitol Hill, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton...
- Hey Obama, Isolate Iran, Or Engage Them - Make Up Your God Damned Mind
From Jonathan Tobin at Commentary: Following the Obama administration’s foreign policy isn’t easy. The president appears to be simultaneously pursuing both dialogue with and outreach toward Iran, while also trying to isolate the Islamic Republic.A...