Green Energy
I have just finished reading Mark Moyar's excellent Triumph Forsaken which is a four hundred page "revisionist" narrative on the Vietnam War 1954-1965. Any work on the Vietnam War that is praised by Stuart A. Herrington, Allan R. Millett and Guenter Lewy should be hard to dismiss out of hand. Although predictably, there will be those who will attempt just that.
Among the villains in Moyar's work were a group of "journalists" who worked to help overthrow the Diem regime when they should have known there was nobody better in line to fill his position. One of those "journalists" was, of course, David Halberstam who died last April. After waiting a decent interval, Moyar has written an article on whether Halberstam was deserving of the fulsome praise heaped upon him as way of eulogy. Halberstam's History:
Read the whole thing. And if you have the time and interest, read Triumph Forsaken. That book provides extensive documentary evidence for the above claims, some of which is recently available for North Vietnam sources.
Crossposted at The Dougout
- And He Does It Again! Now, Apologies Are Insufficient ..ho Chi Minh Inspired By Founders!
Not only was I against the war in vietnam, I helped ORGANIZE demonstrations, waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay back.BECAUSE WE HAD ALMOST NOTHING AT STAKE (Syria anyone?) We therefore had no reason to kill or be killed.But NO ONE doubted that Ho Chi Minh, the NVA,...
- Vietnamese Shrimp Fishers Troubled By "communist Terminology" Of Bp Translators?
Who knows what is going on here? From CNN (via Google cache): The Vietnamese interpreters BP first brought in for safety and cleanup training stirred painful memories and suspicions because they spoke to the elders with a North Vietnamese dialect...
- While You Are Waiting To See If Bush & Co Are So Incompetent They Have Blown It, And Thinking About Nancy Pelosi.....
I am one of those people who see a very clear picture. In our childhood... When we were young boys... I cannot forget the sight of the American forces leaving Vietnam in helicopters, which carried their officers and soldiers. Some Vietnamese, who had...
- What Is Important To The New York Times? And Why?
In his memoirs in 1995, Genl. Giap, who headed North Vietnamese forces from just after the end of WW2 until his retirement in the 90's, the general wrote that the Tet offensive of 2/68 was so destructive to the North Vietnamese and Viet Cong forces,...
- Remember Ari
For those who travel over the Brooklyn Bridge from the East River Drive, you might have wondered why the road leading to the bridge is called the “Ari Halberstam Ramp.” Twelve years ago, a 16-year-old rabbinical student, Ari Halberstam, was gunned...
Green Energy
David Halberstam: Not a Hero
I have just finished reading Mark Moyar's excellent Triumph Forsaken which is a four hundred page "revisionist" narrative on the Vietnam War 1954-1965. Any work on the Vietnam War that is praised by Stuart A. Herrington, Allan R. Millett and Guenter Lewy should be hard to dismiss out of hand. Although predictably, there will be those who will attempt just that.
Among the villains in Moyar's work were a group of "journalists" who worked to help overthrow the Diem regime when they should have known there was nobody better in line to fill his position. One of those "journalists" was, of course, David Halberstam who died last April. After waiting a decent interval, Moyar has written an article on whether Halberstam was deserving of the fulsome praise heaped upon him as way of eulogy. Halberstam's History:
I did not interrupt the paeans with remarks about Halberstam’s gross misdeeds in Vietnam, which I had exposed in a book last year. But now that the funeral period has ended, the media has made clear that Halberstam’s elevation to the status of national hero is intended to be permanent, so in the interest of national history it has become necessary to point out how much Halberstam harmed the United States during his career.
Brazenly attempting to influence history, Halberstam, Sheehan, and Karnow gave Diem’s opponents in the U.S. government negative information on Diem in print and in private. Most of the information they passed on was false or misleading, owing in part to their heavy reliance on a Reuters stringer named Pham Xuan An who was actually a secret Communist agent. The journalists convinced Ambassador Henry Cabot Lodge to accept their reports in place of much more accurate reports from the CIA and the U.S. military, which led Lodge to urge South Vietnamese generals to stage a coup. Press articles suggesting that Diem had lost his principal ally’s confidence made the South Vietnamese generals receptive to coup plots — the Vietnamese elites generally misinterpreted American news reporters as official spokesmen of the U.S. government.
Based on a few faulty pieces of evidence, they contended that the South Vietnamese war effort had crumbled before Diem’s overthrow, not after it. No one of influence succeeded in pointing out that these men’s own articles in 1963 contradicted this claim. The journalists thus succeeded in persuading the American people that Diem, rather than his successors, had ruined the country, and therefore that the press had been right in denouncing him. Newly available American and Vietnamese Communist sources, it turns out, show that the South Vietnamese were fighting very well until the last day of Diem’s life, and that their performance plummeted immediately after the coup because the new rulers purged suspected Diem loyalists and failed to lead.
The Vietnam-era journalists began a tradition that today’s press all too frequently upholds. We hear little from most large press outlets about American heroes in Iraq and Afghanistan—men like James Coffman Jr., Jason Dunham, Danny Dietz, and Christopher Adlesperger who have demonstrated extraordinary bravery in battle—or about our military successes there. Instead of associating the names of heroes with these wars, Americans associate the words they hear most often from the press, like Abu Ghraib and Haditha.
Read the whole thing. And if you have the time and interest, read Triumph Forsaken. That book provides extensive documentary evidence for the above claims, some of which is recently available for North Vietnam sources.
Crossposted at The Dougout
- And He Does It Again! Now, Apologies Are Insufficient ..ho Chi Minh Inspired By Founders!
Not only was I against the war in vietnam, I helped ORGANIZE demonstrations, waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay back.BECAUSE WE HAD ALMOST NOTHING AT STAKE (Syria anyone?) We therefore had no reason to kill or be killed.But NO ONE doubted that Ho Chi Minh, the NVA,...
- Vietnamese Shrimp Fishers Troubled By "communist Terminology" Of Bp Translators?
Who knows what is going on here? From CNN (via Google cache): The Vietnamese interpreters BP first brought in for safety and cleanup training stirred painful memories and suspicions because they spoke to the elders with a North Vietnamese dialect...
- While You Are Waiting To See If Bush & Co Are So Incompetent They Have Blown It, And Thinking About Nancy Pelosi.....
I am one of those people who see a very clear picture. In our childhood... When we were young boys... I cannot forget the sight of the American forces leaving Vietnam in helicopters, which carried their officers and soldiers. Some Vietnamese, who had...
- What Is Important To The New York Times? And Why?
In his memoirs in 1995, Genl. Giap, who headed North Vietnamese forces from just after the end of WW2 until his retirement in the 90's, the general wrote that the Tet offensive of 2/68 was so destructive to the North Vietnamese and Viet Cong forces,...
- Remember Ari
For those who travel over the Brooklyn Bridge from the East River Drive, you might have wondered why the road leading to the bridge is called the “Ari Halberstam Ramp.” Twelve years ago, a 16-year-old rabbinical student, Ari Halberstam, was gunned...