HRW Bowing Down to the King
Hey guys, just found this article online. Don't know how credible it is or whether it has already been covered on IBA, but I thought I'd share--here it goes:
A delegation from Human Rights Watch was recently in Saudi Arabia. To investigate the mistreatment of women under Saudi Law? To campaign for the rights of homosexuals, subject to the death penalty in Saudi Arabia? To protest the lack of religious freedom in the Saudi Kingdom? To issue a report on Saudi political prisoners?
No, no, no, and no. The delegation arrived to raise money from wealthy Saudis by highlighting HRW's demonization of Israel. An HRW spokesperson, Sarah Leah Whitson, highlighted HRW's battles with "pro-Israel pressure groups in the US, the European Union and the United Nations." (Was Ms. Whitson required to wear a burkha, or are exceptions made for visiting anti-Israel "human rights" activists"? Driving a car, no doubt, was out of the question.)
Apparently, Ms. Whitson found no time to criticize Saudi Arabia's abysmal human rights record. But never fear, HRW "recently called on the Kingdom to do more to protect the human rights of domestic workers.
There is nothing wrong with a human rights organization worrying about maltreatment of domestic workers. But there is something wrong when a human rights organization goes to one of the worst countries in the world for human rights to raise money to wage lawfare against Israel, and says not a word during the trip about the status of human rights in that country. In fact, it's a virtual certainty that everyone in Whitson's audience employs domestic servants, giving her a perfect, untaken opportunity to boast about HRW's work in improving the servants' status. But Whitson wasn't raising money for human rights, she was raising money for HRW's propaganda campaign against Israel.
Someone who claims to have worked for HRW wrote to me, "I can tell you that the people on the research and policy side of the organization have little, if any, contacts with people on the donor side." If that's true, apparently this is yet another exception HRW makes for Israel: Ms. Whitson, who gave the presentation to potential Saudi donors, is director of HRW's Middle East and North Africa
Division.
Also, as a Nathan Wagner comments at Opinio Juris: "Surely there is a moral difference between raising funds in free nations through appeals to ideals of universal human rights and raising money in repressive nations through appeals highlighting pressure brought against their enemies. [Moreover], the former type of fundraising does not imperil the organization's mission, but fundraising Bernstein highlights does, since any significant reliance on such funds will necessarily mute criticism of the repressive government."
Finally, some would defend HRW by pointing it that it has criticized Saudi Arabia's human rights record rather severely in the past. The point of my post, though, is not that HRW is pro-Saudi, but that it is maniacally anti-Israel. The most recent manifestation is that its officers see nothing unseemly about raising funds among the elite of one of the most totalitarian nations on earth, with a pitch about how the money is needed to fight "pro-Israel forces," without the felt need to discuss any of the Saudis' manifold human rights violations, and without apparent concern that becoming dependent on funds emanating from a brutal dictatorship leaves you vulnerable to that brutal dictatorship later cutting off the flow of funds, if you don't "behave."David Bernstein, Wall Street Journal.
- Collect The Parking Fines And Send Them On Home
Washington Free BeaconU.N. Human Rights Council Calls for Boycott of U.S. Companies doing business with IsraelU.N.’s war on Israel puts American economy in crosshairsTheWashingtonFree Beaconhas obtained areportsoon to be released by the United Nations...
-
Syria is joining the UN 'Human Rights Council From Will at The Other News: Syria is currently running for a seat on the U.N.’s flagship “human rights” body, the Human Rights Council. Seats are allocated to five regional groups, and just to make...
- Maldives To Run For Seat In Un Council
Foreign minister Dr Ahmed Shaheed travelled to Geneva on Thursday to announce the Maldives’ intention to run for a place on the United Nations Human Rights Council in elections this May.Shaheed has said the human rights reforms which have taken place...
- Storm Track Intimidation: Muslim Refuses To Shake And Loses Prize
Chalk it up to stupidity. Here we have a Muslim asylum seeker who was awarded a prize for his work raising funds for Amnesty International. You know that ultra-Left human rights organization. The organization whose self-appointed task is to make sure...
- Islamic Human Rights Watch
From Little Green Footballs: Our friends the Saudis join with the murderous Sudan regime and the murderous Iranian regime and declare that the “human rights” of Muslims must be “safeguarded:” Human rights of Muslims should be safeguarded. JEDDAH...