Green Energy
HOW AMERICA LOST ITS FOUR GREAT GENERALS
When USMC General John Allen’s retirement was announced in February, our friend Hugh Hewitt called on Victor Davis Hanson to answer the question whether such a drain of military talent — the retirements of Generals McChrystal, Petraeus, Mattis and Allen, in that order — had ever previously occurred in our country’s history over so short a period of time (30 months) because of retirement. “That they occurred during wartime,” Hugh wrote, made “the loss of expertise even more shocking.” Hanson stated there was no parallel. He added that it was a sort of reverse of General George Marshall’s fabled “little black book of talent,” wherein the great American was said to have kept track of the best talents in the military.
In the featured essay of this month’s Commentary, Max Boot explains the misfortune. Commentary has placed Boot’s essay online and I want to draw it to your attention: “How America lost its four great generals.” Boot knows what he is talking about and it is an important essay.
... it is hard to imagine the War on Terror having been waged without four-star commanders such as David Petraeus, Stanley McChrystal, John Allen, and James Mattis. They are among the most illustrious generals produced by the last decade of fighting. They are the stars of their generation. From Iraq to Afghanistan and beyond, they emerged from anonymity to orchestrate campaigns that, after initial setbacks, have given the United States a chance to salvage a decent outcome from protracted counterinsurgencies; they have also literally rewritten the book on how to wage modern war successfully. Yet aside from the similarities in the challenges they faced and the skills they displayed in rising to the task, these men share another, more troubling resemblance: They are either gone from the military or (in the case of Mattis) about to go as of this writing. And for the most part they are leaving under unhappy circumstances. A strong case can be made that all were shabbily treated to one extent or another. Petraeus was hounded out of the CIA and McChrystal out of high command in Afghanistan under a cloud of scandal; Allen saw his reputation unfairly marred by scandal before deciding to call it quits; and Mattis is said to have been pushed out early after clashes with the White House. Certainly none of them was afforded the respect and honors that successful officers at the pinnacle of their career ought to expect—in part to drive younger officers to follow their example and seize the day when their time comes. The treatment of these four remarkable generals at the hands of President Obama and his aides, whatever the merits of each individual case, is likely to rankle within the armed forces and leave those forces less prepared for future challenges.
GO READ THE WHOLE THING.
- Blaze Sources: Obama Purging Military Commanders
Sir? I'm fired, Sir? Sir, Yes, Sir! Can anyone say, "Coup"? From the Blaze: Nine senior commanding generals have been fired by the Obama administration this year, leading to speculation by active and retired members of the military that a purge of...
- Assad Orders Army To Fire Missiles At Israel If He Is Killed
So if he gets run over by an Al Qaeda wannabee from the Muslim Brotherhood, attack the Jews!This goes back to the ancient Quranic dictum… JUST IN CASE, KILL THE JEWSFabulous stuff. Mel Brooks could not com,e up with this kind...
-
New York Times: U.S. Abandoning Hopes for Taliban Peace Deal KABUL, Afghanistan — With the surge of American troops over and the Taliban still a potent threat, American generals and civilian officials acknowledge that they have all but written off what...
- Infidel Man Of The Year
New Centcom Chief Marine Corps Gen. James Mattis: “It’s Fun to Shoot Afghan Men Who Slap Around Women Because They Didn’t Wear a Veil” (WaPo)- President Obama’s pick to lead military operations in Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan and the Middle...
- Obama Moves To Muzzle Top Military Commanders
Newsmax: Obama Moves to Muzzle Top Military Commanders Monday, October 5, 2009 7:42 PM By: David A. Patten Sources tell Newsmax the Obama administration is muzzling its top military leaders, and keeping them from publicly airing their views on how to...
Green Energy
HOW AMERICA LOST ITS FOUR GREAT GENERALS
When USMC General John Allen’s retirement was announced in February, our friend Hugh Hewitt called on Victor Davis Hanson to answer the question whether such a drain of military talent — the retirements of Generals McChrystal, Petraeus, Mattis and Allen, in that order — had ever previously occurred in our country’s history over so short a period of time (30 months) because of retirement. “That they occurred during wartime,” Hugh wrote, made “the loss of expertise even more shocking.” Hanson stated there was no parallel. He added that it was a sort of reverse of General George Marshall’s fabled “little black book of talent,” wherein the great American was said to have kept track of the best talents in the military.
In the featured essay of this month’s Commentary, Max Boot explains the misfortune. Commentary has placed Boot’s essay online and I want to draw it to your attention: “How America lost its four great generals.” Boot knows what he is talking about and it is an important essay.
... it is hard to imagine the War on Terror having been waged without four-star commanders such as David Petraeus, Stanley McChrystal, John Allen, and James Mattis. They are among the most illustrious generals produced by the last decade of fighting. They are the stars of their generation. From Iraq to Afghanistan and beyond, they emerged from anonymity to orchestrate campaigns that, after initial setbacks, have given the United States a chance to salvage a decent outcome from protracted counterinsurgencies; they have also literally rewritten the book on how to wage modern war successfully. Yet aside from the similarities in the challenges they faced and the skills they displayed in rising to the task, these men share another, more troubling resemblance: They are either gone from the military or (in the case of Mattis) about to go as of this writing. And for the most part they are leaving under unhappy circumstances. A strong case can be made that all were shabbily treated to one extent or another. Petraeus was hounded out of the CIA and McChrystal out of high command in Afghanistan under a cloud of scandal; Allen saw his reputation unfairly marred by scandal before deciding to call it quits; and Mattis is said to have been pushed out early after clashes with the White House. Certainly none of them was afforded the respect and honors that successful officers at the pinnacle of their career ought to expect—in part to drive younger officers to follow their example and seize the day when their time comes. The treatment of these four remarkable generals at the hands of President Obama and his aides, whatever the merits of each individual case, is likely to rankle within the armed forces and leave those forces less prepared for future challenges.
GO READ THE WHOLE THING.
- Blaze Sources: Obama Purging Military Commanders
Sir? I'm fired, Sir? Sir, Yes, Sir! Can anyone say, "Coup"? From the Blaze: Nine senior commanding generals have been fired by the Obama administration this year, leading to speculation by active and retired members of the military that a purge of...
- Assad Orders Army To Fire Missiles At Israel If He Is Killed
So if he gets run over by an Al Qaeda wannabee from the Muslim Brotherhood, attack the Jews!This goes back to the ancient Quranic dictum… JUST IN CASE, KILL THE JEWSFabulous stuff. Mel Brooks could not com,e up with this kind...
-
New York Times: U.S. Abandoning Hopes for Taliban Peace Deal KABUL, Afghanistan — With the surge of American troops over and the Taliban still a potent threat, American generals and civilian officials acknowledge that they have all but written off what...
- Infidel Man Of The Year
New Centcom Chief Marine Corps Gen. James Mattis: “It’s Fun to Shoot Afghan Men Who Slap Around Women Because They Didn’t Wear a Veil” (WaPo)- President Obama’s pick to lead military operations in Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan and the Middle...
- Obama Moves To Muzzle Top Military Commanders
Newsmax: Obama Moves to Muzzle Top Military Commanders Monday, October 5, 2009 7:42 PM By: David A. Patten Sources tell Newsmax the Obama administration is muzzling its top military leaders, and keeping them from publicly airing their views on how to...