Could SCOTUS Be The Death Panel For Health-Care Reform?
From Talking Points Memo:
Now that President Obama has signed health-care reform into law, opponents of the bill are pinning their hopes of stopping it on a last-ditch legal strategy. A group of 13 state attorneys general has filed suit (pdf), arguing that the law is unconstitutional.
The bid seems far-fetched at first. But the Roberts Court has recently shown a willingness to strike down landmark legislation -- charges of judicial activism be damned. So, given the stakes, it's worth asking: Could health-care reform have made it through the congressional gauntlet, only to end up dying in the courts?
(Late Update: The Justice Department is signaling that it's already gearing up for a fight. "We will vigorously defend the constitutionality of the health care reform statute," a DOJ spokesman says.)
In recent media appearances, the AGs -- the most high-profile of whom have been Ken Cuccinelli of Virginia, Bill McCollum of Florida, and Henry McMaster of South Carolina -- have made a grab-bag of claims, among them that the bill violates state sovereignty. That's a contention that no court is likely to have much time for. As Steve Schwinn, an associate law professor at John Marshall Law School has written, state laws that aim to override the federal mandate "are almost surely unconstitutional, as conflicting directly with the federal requirement."
The stronger argument in the arsenal of the AGs -- many of whom happen to be running for governor -- relates to the Commerce Clause, the section of the Constitution that empowers Congress to regulate interstate commerce. The AGs focus on the provision of the bill that requires almost all Americans to obtain health insurance. They argue that imposing a penalty on people merely for declining to buy insurance is outside the scope of Congress's power under the Commerce Clause. "For the federal government to be telling people that they must buy health insurance, or they must buy anything at all, is not one of the powers that is give to the federal government by the Constitution," McMaster declared on Fox yesterday. "Nowhere does it say that the federal government can require a private citizen to go out and buy health insurance or anything else. It's not a part of the Commerce Clause power."
This argument isn't, as some reform supporters may wish to see it, merely a bizarre and desperate concoction of the far-right wing -- akin, for instance, to the pseudo-legal arguments advanced by "Constitutionalists" for why Obama's presidency is illegitimate. Over the last six months, it's been embraced by several respected conservative legal scholars. And more importantly, an emerging jurisprudence from the conservative court does show a willingness to limit the scope of the Commerce Clause.
Go read the whole thing.
- Federal Judge:obamacare Unconstitutional
A couple weeks ago and this would have been the BIG story of the day. . . Newsmax: Fla. Judge Strikes Down Health Overhaul Monday, 31 Jan 2011 PENSACOLA, Fla. – A federal judge ruled Monday that the Obama administration's health care overhaul is...
- Obamacare Constitutional? Federal Judge Rules Against Virginia's Challenge To Individual Mandate
BULLSHIT! Am I the only one who is noticing that our government has stepped way beyond the line, way beyond what the British government did to those who started the American Revolution? Here's my individual mandate: The government will not tell me...
-
If at first you don't succeed And you find you can't proceed When the whole bloody crew Doesn't know what to do Well then, brother, it's time to secede -- Midnight Rider's Dad many years ago --(he was none too fond of government) Foxnews:...
- Lefties Explain Why It's All Good
Yeah, it's cool. It's all good. From Rhymes With Cars and Girls: This article about the constitutionality of the health care mandate has a ‘constitutional expert’ make the following rather interesting argument that it falls within the commerce...
- Washington Post Editorial Asks, Is Obamacare Unconstitutional?
From Washington Post: President Obama has called for a serious and reasoned debate about his plans to overhaul the health-care system. Any such debate must include the question of whether it is constitutional for the federal government to adopt and implement...